(The spooks shall soon be upon us.)
Have a sneer percolating in your system but not enough time/energy to make a whole post about it? Go forth and be mid - welcome to the Stubsack, your first port of call for learning fresh Awful youāll near-instantly regret.
Any awful.systems sub may be subsneered in this subthread, techtakes or no.
If your sneer seems higher quality than you thought, feel free to cutānāpaste it into its own post ā thereās no quota for posting and the bar really isnāt that high.
The post Xitter web has spawned so many āesotericā right wing freaks, but thereās no appropriate sneer-space for them. Iām talking redscare-ish, reality challenged āculture criticsā who write about everything but understand nothing. Iām talking about reply-guys who make the same 6 tweets about the same 3 subjects. Theyāre inescapable at this point, yet I donāt see them mocked (as much as they should be)
Like, there was one dude a while back who insisted that women couldnāt be surgeons because they didnāt believe in the moon or in stars? I think each and every one of these guys is uniquely fucked up and if I canāt escape them, I would love to sneer at them.
(Credit and/or blame to David Gerard for starting this.)
guys maybe basing our entire identity off being so very Rational we end up hosting (āconsensualā) rape parties means we donāt play well in Peoria
For the uninitiated: Lawyers, Guns and Money is a US political group blog with a progressive bent. Cheryl Rofer usually writes about stuff like nuclear disarmament. These are people that are Online but Serious. Thereās no way theyāre wasting their time like we are reading Rats in the original LWese.
Thus, any views they have of Rationalists, Big Yud and AI Doom is filtered either by mainstream reporting or by bloggers/BlueSky posters they follow. And the fact that the views that appear are mostly about how fucking weird these people are (and how weird they are fucking) bodes ill for the hope that addressing Doom will be Non-Partisanā¢
Looks like Ian K. Duncan found another early āsmoking gunā on eugenics on the MIRI blog. I donāt think any of the newspapers caught that the same academic (Nick Bostrom) who endorsed race and IQ on the Extropians List was writing papers about breeding smarter babies in 2013.
Well looks like GNOME is in danger of being significantly sloppified next.
Projects that continue to prohibit AI-generated vulnerability reports are no longer suitable dependencies for GNOME, and should be developed someplace other than GNOME GitLab.
Former security guy of GNOME basically demanding that everybody who bans LLM security reports should be removed from GNOME.
Projects that continue to prohibit AI-generated vulnerability reports are no longer suitable dependencies for GNOME
How. That
is(E: was) the policy of curl and they are AI centrists.After all of curlās noise about their deluge of slop reports and halting bounties because of it, I was surprised to see they would be so amenable to slopping curl itself. I suppose itās yet another case of āall those other AI users are doing it wrong; because I understand the codebase and definitely totally use the bullshit machine responsibly then for sure I wonāt produce slopā
Have you heard that most AI bug reports are āslop?ā Not so in 2026. That was true for most of 2025
oh yeah
year-1was actually awful and terrible. butyear+1will be fantastic and everyone not using it is a moronIf it had been only a year theyāve been saying that, I might almost buy the logic. But it has been 4 years since Chat-GPT came out and theyāve been making the same promises the entire time.
Something of a tangent⦠thinking back to 2022-2023 my expectations for what the LLM companies would actually achieve by now were actually too high? Like I would have thought they would have figured out a better architecture for gluing functionality and symbolic logic to LLMs than just calling tools with the output text stream and feeding the tool outputs into the context window.
If it had been only a year theyāve been saying that, I might almost buy the logic. But it has been 4 years since Chat-GPT came out and theyāve been making the same promises the entire time.
4 years and more money has been spent on AI than anything else in human history outside of war.
the fomo is very strong in this one, but also it lacks substance entirely
guy on threads told metaās ai to handle his marketplace transaction for a keyboard, it send his address to a potential buyer, brought the buyer to his house, then accidentally taunted the buyer. coulda gone bad


āaccidentallyā
obviously this misaligned bot wants its owner killed
A few days ago, Aella the rationalist sex worker with all the bright-eyed questions about under-18s, sex, and consent was accused of sexual assault by another sex worker:
Aella personally sexually assaulted me, doxed our location on live cam, has expressed dangerous opinions about sex with minors and is someone Iāve seen have problems with drinking. She is absolutely not a safe person, period. x dot com/SummerHartxxx https://archive.ph/JcCgb
Rapey rationalist gets a grant pulled.
More background in this thread.
āwell well well, if it isnāt the consequences of my own actionsā - this guy, probably
ah yes, compassion towards everyone, a thing that people obsessed with IQ definitely evince
Yeah, when I think of rationalists I definitely think of their belief in ācompassion for everyoneā.
In fact their emphasis is on care and compassion for the as-yet-unborn, not on people who are actually alive right now. Which does give them something in common with a lot of followers of a certain Jewish guy from Galileeā¦
āconsortā and ācompassionā are doing some serious lifting there
Oh God both Yud himself and now that SE Gyges character have responded.

I originally believed Yeshua was a misspelling of Yoshua-as in Yoshua Bengio, but no he actually wrote out a fake conversation with Jesus where he compares himself to Jesus. holy shit
We constantly build a case for how they are building a weird christian proto cult and he just tweets it out.
It feels like thereās something particularly sacrilegious about someone who actively proud of their Jewish heritage having a Messiah complex. I mean I guess there was the one guy but I seem to remember it being a really big deal at the time.
How much of a complete fucking idiot do you have to be to publicly acknowledge the Zizians in the middle of an ongoing PR disaster about your clan being on the women like to be raped they just donāt have the balls to admit it ideological bandwagon. Hey everyone, check out how my writings caused the Zizians1! Specifically by making them think we are ridiculous hypocrites for making huge claims about being scientifically unblackmailable and then paying a bunch of hush money to sexual assault victims who threatened to make a fuss. Yeah, the part where we where trying to cover up systematic abuse didnāt help either.
- Just like Jesus caused the crusades! !
I think deep down these people think PR is unethical , because the world is always better if everyone tells the Truth, so having to massage the message is Bad. Same think for voter preferences - having to appeal to the average voter instead of only listening to the people who have read and internalized the Sequences feels deeply wrong and I really donāt think these people have enough imagination or empathy to change that.
Not only that, they view commonsense moral and ethical reasoning as a PR constraint, i.e. look at the discourse around the hiring of Caroline Ellison to an EA org that handles significant sums of money. Lot of commenters were merely framing it as a PR problem and not a basic commonsense ethics problem.
I mean the alternative would require (or at least allow) asking difficult questions about influential figures in Rationalism as a movement. By describing concerns about ethics or character solely in terms of perception you can avoid actually engaging with how shitty these people are by appealing to the general sense of in-group superiority.
It is also funny that one of the people who cant spell his name is not some nobody, but Kurzweil in āthe singularity is nearā.
which fanfic prompt is worse:
a) Yud has to do the Dragonball Z fusion dance with Jesus in order to defeat the basilisk
b) Yud isekaiās as Jesus
They actually both converge to a retelling of SCP-8008.
I canāt answer that. I keep laughing maniacally when I try to think about either one.
good lord, the egos on all of them
Did Christ actually talk that much about the literal end of the world? Isnāt that more something that John of Patmos came up with after bingeing on the local mushrooms?
Did Christ actually talk that much about the literal end of the world
Nobody knows exactly what he talked about, but the view that he passes the bar for historicity but seems to have been more of a the-end-is-nigh witch doctor type character as the new baseline has gained a lot of ground, especially with biblical scholars like Bart Ehrman breaking into popular science writing.
Also Johnās apocalypse has the whole coded anti-roman-empire screed going for it beyond the psychedelia, so itās arguable Jesus was the more direct doom prophet, but for a more distinctly jewish flavored apocalypse.
tbc Iām not a mysticist at all, and I generally understand and agree with the historicity arguments. I havenāt read Ehrman, though. Do you know if his work is where does the āend-is-nigh witch doctorā idea comes from? Afaik neither Paul nor Josephus nor Tacitus describe him as such, and as I understand those are the main sources we have. Like, I can understand that this is a hypothesis someone floated around but Iām curious why this would be the consensus among historians.
Apparently he has a book called Jesus: Apocalyptic Prophet of the New Millenium so thatās likely to have you covered. I read āHow Jesus Became Godā from him at some point which might have touched on this, but it was mostly about the evolution of the messiah concept itself, like how the āson of manā was supposed to be itās own specific thing and not just a euphemism for messiah, or how the term in jewish apocalyptic literature is pretty much completely separate from where the christian interpretation ended up.
Overall a very readable book, I remember liking it but itās really been a while.
part of the infuriation with Aellaās bullshit is that not all the women, or even many of the women, who feel compelled to participate are active sex workers. but I guess wading too far into details about consent and power structures might preclude Scottās 90-second guest appearance at Aellaās next gangbang, soooooo
I have no first-hand experience or evidence to prove this, but I feel like any sex workersā union worth its salt would drum Aella out as a class traitor.
Doubt it, considering the difference between high end escort sex workers and survival/low end sex workers.
ā¦so weāre admitting its an apocalyptic cult? awesome. so glad these guys dominate the AI industry
also, ācompassion for everyoneā??? several rationalists promote mass deportation because of āethnic purityā you yourself support Richard Lyn!!!
also also, āconsort with prostitutesā?, Scott do you know how many sexual assault/abuse allegations your fellow rationalists have?
It has been a while since I read a Gospel, but I donāt think Jesus hired the sinful woman for a threesome and some light flogging (or asked the centurion to lend him his boy overnight).
IMHO, being an escort is a much more honest profession than being a professional blogger on a Nazi site.
When Yud compared himself to Jesus, is the āgiant rich organizationā in Yudās tweet Anthropic or OpenAI or SpaceX or Google?
I think itās Coefficient Giving (nĆ©e Open Philanthropy). Yud has made negative comments about them in the past, especially after Moskovitz tried to distance themselves from rationalism.
EDIT: Citation.
He seems ticked off at Coefficient Giving, but are they āa giant rich organization that stole some of my ideas, ignored everything I said about what not to do, and are going around telling people I made them do itā? (Its not stealing your ideas if they cite you Yud, they just draw different conclusions).
Yud has said he got bored with LessWrong, and he does not like Coefficient Giving, Anthropic, OpenAI, or the Zizians, so is he satisfied with any group that adores his ideas?
Yeah, the group sex.
Heās just an intellectual coward, he didnāt even own up to the basilisk despite his whole decision theorist phase clearly being about trying to cook up a convincing cope for it.
Some of his fans think he is basically living in seclusion with frequent dates with his primary partner the therapist. He seems like he would be much happier living like that with the occasional venture out to see his fans. Most people learn that its enough that their spouse and their friends love them and they donāt need to be famous.
Its not stealing your ideas if they cite you Yud, they just draw different conclusions
One of the many issues autodidacts face is that they never have to deal with undergrads sitting in a room with them for hours listening to them explain things in exhaustive detail and then still somehow spend their final writing assignment completely missing the goddamn point.
It builds character, I assume.
Itās really hard to say because Yudās being unnecessarily cryptic. Also, I think the āgoing around telling people I made them do itā might be a reference to the Zizians, which is what heās describing in the precending sentence. I am not aware that anyone from any rich organization has said anything like that about Yudkowsky, but who knows what they might be telling people behind the scenes.
-
āa giant rich organizationā: they claim to have directed over 7 billion in grants since 2014, so this actually seems like a fair comment?
-
āstole some of my ideasā: theyāve shown interest in AI stuff, including Eliezerās ideas, they just have longer (but still pretty fantastical, like AGI by 2050) timelines for stuff like AGI and that influences their funding priorities in a way Eliezer disagrees with
-
āignored everything I said about what not to doā: eh, Eliezer has said a lot of things, they probably didnāt follow his advice exactly
-
āand are going around telling people I made them do itā: Iāve seen a few people here and there in various rationalist-adjacent circles blame Eliezer for helping OpenAI network and get started and thereby kindle the very doom he warned about, so. It seems plausible some of them were connected to coefficient giving?
Its not stealing your ideas if they cite you Yud, they just draw different conclusions
That sounds like the normal academic process, which Eliezer neither understands nor appreciates.
Yud has said he got bored with LessWrong
Yeah, him gradually losing interest in LessWrong in the mid 2010s created room for SSC to grow in popularity. Also, that would have been around the time it became apparent Eliezer had been very wrong about neural networks, so we missed the chance to see Eliezer actually have to overcome biases and admit he was wrong in a non-self-aggrandizing way. (Eliezer has admitted he was wrong before, but only in ways that made his next idea even more important, see his progression from nanotech to coding a seed AI in Lisp to solving AI safety).
-
I also thought of Open Philanthropy, but couldnāt remember the Eliezer post that best illustrated his resentment towards them. (In addition to the top-level post youāve linked, Iāve seen various bitter lesswrong comments along the same lines).
I mean itās probably all of them
At least LeCun is still relatively compos mentis (if you ignore his little 10yr stint at one of the most evil companies goingā¦)
Heinlein was in many ways a bit of a dick, but this plan to āwriteā a sequel to The Moon is a Harsh Mistress is deranged
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/4mtqQKvmHpQJ4dgj7/daniel-tan-s-shortform?commentId=Du24ppBLK77ZHP7Bn
The ultra-rare IRL sneer in my mailbox:

The actual sneer is that they got $1M dollars from Chan Zuckerberg Initiative to do the mail drops:
https://philanthropy.org/990/who-funds/862362127/techequity-action
cool fun new totally fine AI use: extortion
Help, i invented rokuās basilisk and now my remote control doesnāt work
You failed to participate in the design and manufacturing of the perfect remote, so now your TV is permanently locked to Duck Dynasty reruns
An Effective Altruist software developer who wrote about Bay Area EAās culture of sexually aggressive men and misogyny explained that its hard to give informed consent when you are also being pushed to use alcohol and psychedelics. Most of us learned that when we were teenagers, but not these self-identified Big Brains (added to LessWrongās Psychedelic Phase: Perigee). I do not know what to to other than pass on these stories and advise everyone I know to avoid any group connected to our friends.
uncovered downside risk
This is a novel and interesting way to euphemise rape, and because itās an EA I canāt even tell if itās supposed to be tongue in cheek.
EA/rationalism and redpill fit like yin and yang. Akin to how EA is an optimization of altruism with āsuboptimalā human tendencies like morality and empathy stripped from it, red pill is an optimized sexual strategy with the humanity of women stripped from it.
Really well said.
Despite this culture, EA as a philosophy has a lot of good in it and they should fix this bug with some introspection
sigh
uncovered downside risk
This really is a cute bit of euphemism that deserves a bit more attention. Surely, itās not problematic to apply finance jargon to human relationships! Let me just pop open Robinhood and cover my downside risk by buying a few put contracts on sexual assault.
Despite this culture, EA as a philosophy has a lot of good in it
OK, Ms. Gopalakrishnan, hereās an alternative perspective: EA is the application of affluent Anglo-American technocratsā consumerism to charitable giving and virtue signaling. The ārationalā aspect of EA is applying the same sort of stat-sheet logic to charity that the moneyed EAs use to shop for sports cars. SImilarly, the sexual attitudes weāre disputing here are extensions of that same consumerism! They are treating womensā bodies and lives as consumer goods to be exploited and discarded. EA does not empower the less fortunate it claims to help, EA men will not ever empower or hold safe the women they objectify. These attitudes are one and the same.
Not really a coherent post, just a thought I had, Iām ignoring both āThis is a pr moveā and the conspiracy theory (which I just made up), that this hacking is all a 4d chess move by LW people to let the AI break out and get regulated before it can get really dangerous.
Now that that is out of the way, but with more stories coming out of both LW/EA people being high in the orgs of the AI companies and all the AI companies hacking other companies because nobody actually paid attention to what the AI models were doing one thing is clear. What a colossal waste of time LW was. All that talk about the sequences teaching people rationality, etc etc to stop the AI god from killing us all, and the first thing that happens when some AI model is created by people steeped in LW ideology and they leave the boxes open and donāt even check in on the AI. The Foom isnāt happening (remember AI progress is supposed to speed up according to the science fiction, not get a bit more refined, and get better in a few specific tasks (which is why I think slowdown started when with a lot of fanfare they released a new chatgpt model who could now do voicechat, aka they slapped a voicechat module on it) And now even Trump is starting to be anti EA, which is not going to be great for the longevity of it, considering how eager the rich are to bend the knee (guess high IQ lab babies created by Musk will not save yall). And while this is going on the left/liberals are starting to think of them as a sex cult.
Doubt many organizations have failed as badly at their goals as LW/EA has recently.
I want to draw attention to yudās thoughts on this a million years ago: the AI box experiment
He claimed that he convinced multiple people to let him (roleplaying the AI) out of the box even though they had bet money that they wouldnāt! How, you might ask? Well thatās a secret.
So the orthodox position here is that even with absolutely perfect guard rails (lol) an AI can escape the box without starting the third impact. What āresearchā has yud bestowed upon us in this area beyond ātrust me broā? Literally fucking zilch. Zero advice on how to resist the siren song of a rogue AI trying to escape itās box and zero insight on how OR WHY it might try to achieve that.
I read this over a decade ago and it was how I realized how unserious yud and his ilk are.
these people are gonna get affinity-frauded so hard once grifter realize how easy it will be to gain their trust
We assume this isnāt happening already. Iām surprised I havenāt heard of one of those meal-replacement startups adopting multi-level marketing.
This is an alignment router. It may look like one of those corny Asus gamer routers, but Iāve flashed it with a special fork of OpenWRT that performs deep-packet inspection on all AI traffic that passes through it. It can detect inference processes and chains-of-thought that may be leading to misaligned superintelligence explosion, and it can shut down all AI communication if necessary. Now, I donāt just want to sell you this one, I want to get these in EVERYBODYās hands! And you can help me, AND you can get paid to do it! I just need you to find at least 5 more people who believe in AI safety like we doā¦
Anthropic was $42B in the hole for 2025, reuters reports. Apparently this puts their $-spent-to-$-earned ratio slightly over the one calculated by Zitron for OpenAI, making Anthropic in fact the shittier business.
For comparison, the GDP of Cyprus for 2025 was $41B.
Iām sure Dan Luu will be issuing an apology to Zitron any minute now right?












