You must log in or # to comment.
Good intentions and all, but the full video context (the vehicle just keeps going and the blocker moves out of the way after several seconds of nudging) makes this a terrible example that only reinforces the sense of futility, in my opinion.
Not saying not to stand and fight, but this isn’t the posterchild to use.
Perception is more powerful than reality. You think the tankman from china actually accomplished much. But he is still a symbol today.
It’s more than any of us have done. Often, genuine actions and words are much stronger than any impact they may initially have.
Tankman travels through time!
Humvee Man
Direct link to the actual toot source.
The second image is a bit on the nose IMO. The comparison was clear enough from the original. And yeah maybe some people need it pointed out to them, but I suspect those people are also the ones who will reject the idea regardless.
There are probably some out there, especially younger people or those who have only recently started educating themselves, who simply haven’t seen the second image before.
Maybe, but I’d say if they don’t know Tank Man, seeing it in this context without further explanation is still unhelpful. Because they’re likely to think it’s a photo taken in America today.
I’m just thinking about the Venn diagram of people who know who George Takei is, are of the right kind of mind that they would actually see the link between the two images, but have not seen the second image.
Probably not a huge overlap but then again adding it for even just a few doesn’t do any harm.
He shares it, people who follow him share it with people they know, which may include some fringe magas, and maybe even some full-blown magats.
not to mention the amount of people who dont know its a still of a video with tiananmen square in the background.
i didn’t even see the guy in the first picture until i looked at the second and realized what i should be looking for
Huh, fair enough.
One person stopping a vehicle, the other judging the people in the vehicle like a disappointed parent.
“Do your mothers know what you’re doing?”
“Would your Grandmother be happy with you right now?”
“You aren’t being the neighbor that Fred Rogers knew you could be!”
I’m always amazed at how powerful that single sentence is to almost all Americans.
Wait until the tankies come in here and tell you this guy was trying to stop them from leaving and asking them to go back and detain more immigrants while also claiming there were no immigrants there anyways
If you are talking about tank man i can just show you you can clearly see tiananmen square in the background and the direction the tanks are going and where the guy is pointing.
can’t wait for that one guy from .ml to show up and argue that Tiananmen Square was a peaceful protest and post links claiming that there were no deaths recorded there.
You dont need to make a strawman of what mls believe, you can just quote the wikipedia and ignore the claims by countries that have a reason to fabricate hostile evidence. If you want to go further, look at testimonies by witnesses that corroborate the side opposed to where they currently live.
Its also important to try to understand why the chinese feel the issue is contentious and the various perspectives, as opposed to letting the other side tell you how the chinese feel and why.
There were no deaths recorded there though. Here is what a reporter of the washington post who was in Beijing at the time says about that.
10 men!
In the U.S, our tanks would run them over
this is in the US
Yes, I was making the comparison to that one event in China to this event (in the u.s) saying that our tanks (literal or metaphorical for a member of a military convoy) would run over our protestors instead of stopping.
I want to see the US soldier who swore to uphold the US Constitution operating a tank run down US citizens on US soil. Then we will know for sure China has won.
Why does it have to be specifically a tank?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:United_States_military_killing_of_American_civilians
china???
Is this the operation where their was child labour of illegal immigrants and then someone started shooting at the ice officers?
LOL, nice try with the blatant dishonest spin. Too bad your attempt to falsely paint ICE as the ‘good guys’ falls flat if you’ve got two brain cells to rub together and realize that they were there to kidnap the workers, not arrest the owners.
You mean unlike using real American citizens’ children as laborers, legally? Because I’m pretty sure the current administration is all for legalizing child labour.
I dunno, last I heard about child labour from the US was all those factories being busted employing children. But I might get it confused with the children being shot in school, or the children with cancer being sent to Auschwitz. Its’ really hard to tell, what I do know is that the Republicans care about children and this is reflected in their actions.
As for shooting ICE, that’s a civic duty.
I believe there’s a whole section in the American Constitution that essentially covers this eventuality.
Who let the racist dirtbag in here? Were the immigrants also eating babies and worshipping Satan according to your source?
Not racist just making sure everyone had the facts.
How is asking a question sharing facts? If you had facts, you would have linked them. You clearly don’t.
Its not my job to educate you. U can see my clearly rhetorical question and use Google to find out that it is in fact true.
And I’m sure those poor exploited children will be so much happier in El Salvador.
