I am quite out of the loop …
This is zelda but mario games soul caliber and some others are also being hit with bad reviews
What is this “we” I see people use recently?
I have a feeling there may be an artificial push to justify GTA6 being the GOTY, since the moves I’ve noticed are quite similar to social engineering in politics. Planting doubt now of which is the best regarded game by means of many difuse means, reviews included but not just them, allows to justify a given result if someone complains about it, by pointing to the planted indirect information. And to not be too obvious of a manipulation for the sake of social engineering, if that’s indeed the case, the bad reviews spilling to other titles would dillute the impression of an isolated case.
Why does anyone care about Metacritic “user” ratings, where anyone can give a rating no matter if they own or played the game?
I think most people don’t really care, but when someone has a beef with a company, leaving a bad review makes them feel better.
I don’t actually mean the reviewers themselves. Those bombers are hopeless anyway. I actually was thinking about those who look at the rating and care about its value, like this post or a few YouTubers talking about it.
It’s the inverse i think. One group has a beef with the company, one group feels tribal attachment to the company, as said, best to just not engage. There’s also the possibility of review bots, paid bad reviews, etc. and that also goes for journalistic reviews. Watch gameplay footage, find a pro reviewer that thinks like you, those are your best bets
Ah, gotcha. Yeah, I don’t know why those folks would care either.
Also, if some form of verification for legitimacy is desired, there’s also NeoDB which uses ActivityPub and can crosspost to Bluesky too.
So if someone acts suspicious and has no other presence online associated to that account, his reviews can be dismissed.
Or even, if it adds some form of weight sorting or filter, similar to Steam’s “helpful reviews”, it could help too.
I think the best way is to proof ownership by connecting your account to Metacritic. And then add a filter to show ratings (and reviews) from those who have the game. This still can be used to review bomb, but at least it comes from someone who has the right to downvote the game (or upvote).
I don’t think the NeoDB is a good way to check legitimacy of a review or account. This does not proof the person owns or played the game, its just a heuristic if this account maybe a bot or not. I also find it a bit creepy to find person by the email.
Steam is on another level here. They have reviews from those who have the game. Which in itself solves most of the problems I have with Metacritic user reviews. Plus they try to identify unrelated review bombs and exclude those ratings, such as what happened to Zelda (normal review bombs with a good reason and related to the game are not excluded BTW). Metacritic has the power to do this, but only with proof of ownership, such as connecting various accounts.
I suppose there’s a problem with any solution, though each gives a way to mitigate issues.
My case for example, I’ve got Zelda OOT physical, but last I connected my Switch 2 to the internet was 4 months ago, right after I got it, so I could test some things, but I never logged to Nintendo’s services with an account.
So if I am to make a review and prove I did play it, I guess other means of mitigation would be to have commented my impressions of the game as I played and linked them to the review, posting screenshots and videos, linking a photo of my game in hands…
And on another point, the idea of verified owners’ reviews, GOG does and it generally works, though GOG’s scope is much smaller so Idk how it’d work on sites and networks like Metacritic and NeoDB. Worth a test though!
gta 6 is getting reviewbombed so gta 6 fans are review bombing other games in revenge
Next time I feel like a loser I need to remind myself that people care about metacritic reviews enough to spend their time review bombing
Makes perfect sense. If you are a GTA 6 player.
(no shade on players, just a meme reply here, I plan on playing this game myself)
That’s like “You throw shit at my house so i shot your dog and burned down your neighborhood” situation and it wasn’t even your dog. I haven’t seen so much review activity ever to be honnest and I make reviews on meta critic a lot.
The correct question is why some people stop. Nintendo is one of the most anti-customer and overall shittiest companies.
Very Moloch vs Ball argument
Critics manipulation.






