This is a broad question meant to cover multiple pathways as to what is considered mainstream media. They can be character representatives, ongoing series or what have you.
I’m going to elect to focus on the general sense of the appeal of mainstream media. To me, mainstream media is a manufactured construct that is built to market. It is plastic, it plays safe, it relies on predictability, it re-runs the same formula, it never challenges itself .etc And nothing really remains as a point of some permanent progress, if but only temporarily before falling back to status quo.
It’s vanilla as vanilla can be, which is okay in doses, but not okay in large quantities. And to help clarify some things too, is that I’m not focused on news organizations because there are entertainment venues as well to consider. I know a lot of people will immediately think of some news broadcasting station they don’t like because of the filtered malformed information projected to push agendas or appease certain demographics to influence votes or opinions on a wide scale.
I’m just interested to see what people come up in their own words about what thing from mainstream media that they don’t like about it.
I was so excited by iron man and avengers but by endgame I was pretty much out. Doctor strange got me to watch but disapointed and two was oof. At this point super hero films are a watch as it comes up free conveniently (and yes I know I could sail the seas but honestly its not even worth that effort). I kinda feel the last thing I was excited by what it actually put out was america gods season 1 and season 2 cured me of that. My heydey of media is essentially firefly series wise and lord of the rings movie wise. So early aughts which kinda precedes the height of tech to me the iphone kinda was the begining of the end. Like a mac with osx that had a wireless with a few drives that you backed up your laptop to and held your itunes stuff and all of it you could bring to a mac store and they would fix no questions asked. that was an amazing time. osx server edition you could just install and check a bunch of boxes and have a slew of self hosted things going in a snap.
It’s mostly all negative news about how the world is going to shit. Why would I subject myself to constant negativity? I’m not a masochist.
The few positive news articles that do come out usually have people trying to spin them into something negative. I’m just sick of the constant pessimism.
Ads.
To summarize the summary of the summary: people are a problem.
News articles.
TITLE OF THE ARTICLE
Subheading saying Title of the Article
Introductory paragraph saying the same thing as Title of the Article
In Brief
Title of the Article
Article
… where some opinionista breathlessly expands the Title of the Article into 15 paragraphs, often repeating themselves, and including links to similar articles from other opinionistas.
Related Content
Title of Essentially the Same Article, But Slightly Different
And without adblocking: several ads every paragraph or two, definitely autoplay video ad across the top banner, and one in the bottom right. 15 seconds into reading, not one, but 3 separate modal ads covering most of the page.
That they sell genocide, rampant corruption and the predatory healthcare system as “centrist”
bought by mostly CONSERVATIVE owners, issuing propaganda only sources, plus copaganda/military ganda shows.
So, I just am not as much of a live action fan anymore. Modern live action shows have this quality I cannot put into words that drives me away compared to say Avatar: Seven Havens or some other cartoons/anime/whatever. Somehow differs from older media of the live action variety, which I tend to enjoy a lot more.
Besides that, the whole fakeness of every single competition show out there sucks so mycht. You’ll be given someone who is auditioning and it just feels like they were given a script to memorize that dramatizes their life story enough that I can’t vibe with it. Even if the events are real, I cannot stand them.
What media? All I get is ads, with brief breaks for ads-disguised-as-something-else.
Too much of it is owned by billionaires who use it to foster their neo liberal, libertarian or outright fascist agenda.
It’s so forceful that even public media repeats the same narrative only to show they still are in the loop.
Does mainstream media even exist anymore? Everyone’s off in their own silos getting fed exactly what they already believe and want to hear.
I hear people talking about their news sources and I’ve never heard of them anymore but inevitably those sources have millions of followers.
I don’t think I live under a rock; I’ve probably just siphoned myself into my own silos getting fed without even realizing it.
See Netflix creating bland, formulaic content based explicitly for genre and content tagging to appeal to demographics who are expected to be glancing up from their phones on occassion.
I tried to watch something recently on Netflix and it was so boring it put me to sleep. It was about someone’s dad being put into an A.I. or something but literally nothing ever happened
You should switch to Prime so you can watch the series they did on Melania Trump. You will likely have an out-of-body experience from the boredom.
Old people and poor people still watch a lot of broadcast TV (over the air with antenna) and cable TV. Satellite TV is probably going extinct for the most part.
Streaming services are consolidating with several mega-corps homogenizing their content into similar garbage piles.
Mainstream media does.
It treats me like I’m a fucking idiot. It pisses on my leg ans tells me it’s raining. It wants me to feel angry, afraid, and miserable. It wants me to feel inadequate so that I buy the crap advertised to me.
It’s a man in an ivory tower, who thinks he’s better than me, telling me all the flaws in my life so I’ll accept his solutions to them.
I don’t need that to have a happy life.
Is designed to deceive you
I support mainstream media. I believe the public requires access to reliable news, and you simply cannot rely on information from random internet users alone. Someone has to do the work of verifying information. You may not like the format they present the news in, but you would be so much worse off without them.
I kind of agree with this in theory. The idea of mainstream media is good: big, broad news outlets that have a lot of eyes on them from a lot of different perspectives, which means that they have more incentive to stay nuanced and truthful – as opposed to influencers, gurus and other niche outlets that can get away with all kinds of crap as long as they’re preaching to their choir.
I don’t know how this works in other countries, but here in Norway, the unions for journalists and editors also get together with media organizations to run a kind of tribunal for journalistic ethics. You generally won’t be considered a serious mainstream journalistic medium unless you’re part of that arrangement.
Combine that with competition from strong and serious public media, and you get something that’s not perfect, but pretty good. Without those factors, I’m not so sure.
We’d be worse off than re-electing Trump? Please explain all the benefits of mainstream media that has led to a flowering democracy and an equal, just society.
I’m not the person you’re replying to, but I should think the case would be that the downfall of mainstream media is part of the reason why democracies are struggling.
Depends on how you define it, really.
The criticism of the left is that mainstream media hamstrings any leftist world building, is constantly carrying water for economic conservatism, is very poor about identifying and labelling problems, etc… and that this universal tendency of the MSM leads ultimately to fascism as people needs and solutions to those needs are continually shut out of conversation.
And the MSM has always been like that. We’ve had a few highlights, of course, and I think many of us have an internalized ideal of what journalism should be–relentless in its pursuit of truth and holding power accountable; but, historically, the truth has been much different.
You might get a kick out of media criticism podcasts. If you’re really on the left, CitationS Needed podcast is excellent. If you’re more mainstream, NPR’s On The Media is fantastic (if its still on the air). And of course, baby’s first step into the idiocy of “the news” is always the Daily Show.
I think the argument would go that American democracy worked a lot better before the media started fragmenting in the late 80’s – and that the internet has increased that fragmenting even more.
Thanks for the tips. I’m a long time fan of the Daily Show, and consider myself fairly leftist, so I’ll check out Citations Needed – but it’s good to have an alternative, since I’ve previously found a lot of American leftist podcasts to be kind of obnoxious :p
That’s a weird argument to be making. The 1980’s kicked off an era of media consolidation. More media is in the hands of fewer people than ever before.
And the “fragmentation” we’re seeing from podcasts, youtube, and other non-controlled media are doing the real work of journalism that mainstream outlets are not. The public’s turn against Israel started because TikTok gave them a clear view into the reality of the genocide. So, of course, TikTok had to be controlled and sold to American Zionists.
I think the better argument is that fragmented media is going to save us. If you give people the freedom to see which narratives fit their own reality better, you’re going to, on the aggregate, have people with a better view of reality than from imbibing the Meganarrative that benefits the ruling class. And, yes, you will also get some crazy racist shit, too, but, like, that’s also kind of controlled media if you look at the funding for AM talk radio.
Also the early history of the United States was absolutely WILD when you look at the little presses people had to slander their political opponents and push their causes…
I’m not going to make the claim any society on our planet is just.
However it seems the countries with state backed broadcasting given relatively free hands. As long as they report as factually as they can, tends to do better
Is a free and fair press the cause of a well-ordered society, or its result?
And what state-backed broadcasting compay are you submitting as an example?






