• 0 Posts
  • 39 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: January 16th, 2022

help-circle
rss






  • 🦆 what’s the name for the logical fallacy of incorrectly calling something “no true scotsman”

    I wasn’t making a generalisation about the identity of leftists, I was saying that “[PC enthusiasts using the term ‘master race’ to refer to themselves represents] no glorifying of Nazism” is not a leftwing position. this distinction is possible because “left wing” has definitions beyond just “what people who call themselves ‘leftwing’ think”, like promoting social equality, and fighting entrenched hierarchies.

    having some leftwing views (and taking leftwing actions, which, nice, thank you for your service, I’ve done a lot more than shout at someone, get teargassed, or go to a pride march, not saying you don’t get an opinion though…) doesn’t automatically make your support for using the term “master race” less rightwing.

    anyway, “I’m as left as I fucking want to be” is a lot less ridiculous a thing to say than “I’m as left as they come”.


  • The holocaust is genuinely a tragedy but the only thing connecting it and a joke about PC inferiority/superiority complex are only connected in your perspective

    No, what’s connecting the two is the use of term “master race”, a literal piece of Nazi ideology… which also makes war crimes more than tangentially related.

    If your “fun” is causing marginalised people to feel bad then you’re punching down, and you need a better sense of humour.




  • this just sounds even less believable: you’re in a jursidiction where the amount of data you have to store on students is exactly specified, and you’re liable to prosecution for storing any single piece of data less or more? I would appreciate extraordinary evidence for this extraordinary claim.

    anyway, even if that’s true, you could be using your knowledge to help privacy-conscious students like OP, instead of throwing a rulebook at them and casting aspersions about their motivations. I return to “reconsider your views, and the impact of your job”.




  • we are very screwed, in large part because of people like you, enthusiastically volunteering to help with propaganda in support of corporate real estate and retail tycoons.

    you could be part of the solution by wearing a mask.

    perhaps research the effects of repeated COVID infections on otherwise-fine people, reconsider how transmission and probability works (“oh, there’s no point using condoms, anyone I have any kind of sex with is likely to get HIV from someone else”), and try and imagine how you’d feel if you or someone you care about had an immune system disorder and couldn’t safely go outside in your area because of healthier people who prioritise their comfort in not wearing a small piece of cloth on their faces




  • trivialising a student’s desire for privacy as being about playing videogames is a lot more ridiculous than anything the OP said.

    maybe rethink your uncritical support for surveillance, and either organise with your coworkers to make your school’s policies more respectful of its students, or find a less unethical job.